Celtic Sunrise
Diana Leatham
Contents
-
-
-
- The Far Western Christian Civilization Of The Celts.
- The Catholic Church Before The Dark Ages.
- The Celtic Church In Britain.
- The Celtic Church In Scotland.
- The Celtic Church In Ireland.
- The Celtic Church In Brittany.
- The Celtic Church In England.
- The Celtic Church Abroad.
-
-
Introduction
After a service broadcast from Iona a correspondence wrote that she was a Roman Catholic and her father of the Church of Scotland persuasion. Each claimed St. Columba as their exclusive possession. Engagingly she asked that I settle the matter to prevent any rift in a very happy home. Wishing that peace might be preserved, with honour, I felt justified in paraphrasing slightly Lewis Carroll and assuring her that “both had won the race and both would receive prizes.”
There is some nonsense written on both sides, due in the main to a lack of historical perspective. We are all opt to forget that papal claims, as now understood were nowhere being made in St. Columba’s day: that the Eternal City had still an historic pre-eminence which gave natural priority to anyone who was Bishop of Rome: and that variations in the dating of Easter or the mode of tonsure were but two of many discrepancies in a still organic, as opposed to a rigorously institutional, Church. Much was still in solution. Unity was still conceived of as enriched, and not endangered, by variation on a common theme. Rigorous uniformity had not yet emerged to bedevil love.
In such an atmosphere St. Columba could, and did, send his best poem, on the glories of Creation, to the Pope. The Pope thrilled to its genius but failed to place it in the Vatican Library as only one verse made reference to the Salvation wrought on Calvary. St. Columba, nettled, wrote his great Redemption Hymn.
But in such an atmosphere the Celtic Church could, and did also, protest an autonomy, proud variants and an inner freedom that could fully justify claim of independence had such a phrase been the order of the day. Did they hold the full Catholic Faith? Yes, no more and no less than did the Church of Rome. Yes: no more and no less than the Roman Church and the Church of Scotland hold it today.
Toynbee, in his Study of History, goes so far as to entitle one crossed-road on the path of Christian Civilization – “Iona or Rome?” What was the essential colloquy that was taking place in Christian minds at that point in our programme? It was but a new variant of an everlasting and necessary tension. St. Peter and St. John were both true disciples of our Lord, Who for ever points us both to a narrow gate and to wide horizons. Both can be in the direction of the sunrise. St. Peter, with his keys, was consumed with the problem of the gate. St. John, of the mountain-top, was entranced with the nearness of the land that was very far off. It is no accident that the last remaining relic of the Celtic Church on Iona is St. John’s Cross, standing just outside the Roman period Abbey; at the laying of whose earliest foundation stone, that cross, by then already old, stood sentinel. Nor is it accident that St. John was the patron saint of Scotland for centuries before the Roman dominance placed in his stead St. Andrew. Least of all, perhaps, was it accident that this same cross was smashed to smithereens. The keys demolished it.
The modern mind, unused to personal symbols, labels them same issue as the tension between the institutional and the organic.
In the section of history with which this book deals, Miss Leatham elucidates the splendid stand then made for the organic interpretation of the Gospel; for the Church of the Spirit of St. John.
Peter, of course, won. The Roman Institution prevailed. Nor let anyone suppose that the organic conception was recovered in sixteenth-century Geneva. Calvin renounced the Institution only to write the Institutes. Nor let anyone further blaspheme that the many centuries of institutional dominance, “Catholic” or “Reformed”, were not in the providence of God. He is in no hurry and must discipline His child before He frees him. But are we now entering “the age of the Spirit”?
It was at the turn into the present century that nearly all the bits into which St. John’s Cross on Iona had been scattered were again gathered together and made one. The old cross, restored, stands sentinel over the new building. Prophetic?
Are the persecuted Russian seers of modern times correct who say that, for those with eyes to see, we have already entered the age of the Spirit? Does the future experience and expression of the Faith lie with the organic? There is that in the new atomic theory of the nature of matter which may form permanent base for such constructions.
Were the Celtic Saints instinctive moderns before their time? A whole book awaits the writing on some such theme. But a prior necessity is the recovery of true history. Miss Leatham gives it here in brilliant distillation. Scotland’s ablest Church historian scanned its every page and claim, and his correction was confined to a solitary date!
The book blows sky high much popular “institutional” propaganda. Should it be honoured by a reply, I trust the research that goes to its construction will be as painstaking as has been Miss Leatham’s.
Her earlier book, They Built on Rock, has rejoiced very many readers. Any contestant of her present claims will find this book is also built on rock.
George F. MacLeod
Iona. May, 1950.